How to Conduct an Internal Billing Audit Before a CMS Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) Arrives

Internal billing audit to prepare for a CMS Recovery Audit Contractor review

An internal billing audit lets you find and fix Medicare billing errors before a Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) or another Medicare contractor finds them for you. It reviews a sample of your own paid claims against the medical record and Medicare rules, measures your error rate, and turns each finding into a fix. Done well, it lowers recoupment risk and shows auditors a working compliance program.

Quick answer: Pull a random sample of recent Medicare claims in your highest-risk areas, review each one against the documentation and payment rules, and calculate both a claim error rate and a dollar error rate. Refund confirmed overpayments, correct the root causes, and repeat the audit on a schedule so you are ready when a RAC request arrives.

Key takeaways

  • Know the stages: RAC reviews move from data analysis to records requests, findings, discussion, recoupment and appeal.
  • Know TPE too: Medicare Administrative Contractors run Targeted Probe and Educate reviews of 20 to 40 claims per round.
  • Target your risk: Use the OIG Work Plan and your own data to choose what to audit.
  • Measure two error rates: Track the share of claims in error and the share of dollars in error.
  • Act on findings: Return confirmed overpayments and fix the process that caused them.

Why an Internal Billing Audit Comes Before the RAC

Recovery Audit Contractors review Medicare fee-for-service claims after payment to find improper payments, both overpayments and underpayments. They work under contingency arrangements, so they focus on claim types with a history of errors. Recovery Auditors can generally review claims up to three years after the date of payment.

An internal billing audit puts you on the same timeline. It finds the same errors a RAC would look for, while you still control the response. In addition, a documented audit program helps show good faith if an external review does find problems.

Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) Audit Stages

Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) audit stages follow a set path, and each stage has its own deadlines. Knowing them helps you plan your response before a letter arrives.

  1. Data analysis: The RAC uses claims data to pick an issue, from topics CMS has approved for review.
  2. Automated or complex review: Automated reviews use claims data alone. Complex reviews start with an additional documentation request (ADR) for medical records.
  3. Review results: For complex reviews, the RAC sends its findings, and CMS has shortened that timeline to 30 days after it receives the records.
  4. Discussion period: CMS's summary of Recovery Audit program improvements explains that auditors must wait 30 days for a discussion request before sending claims to the MAC for adjustment.
  5. Recoupment and appeal: The MAC issues a demand letter. The first appeal level is a redetermination by the MAC, which you can request within 120 days of the demand letter. If you file within 30 days, recoupment does not start while the MAC reviews it. Later levels include a reconsideration by a Qualified Independent Contractor, an Administrative Law Judge hearing, the Medicare Appeals Council and federal court.

ADR limits also matter. CMS sets them by provider and ties them to each provider's denial rate, so providers with lower denial rates receive fewer requests. As a result, a strong internal billing audit program can reduce how many records you have to send.

The Targeted Probe and Educate (TPE) Process

The Targeted Probe and Educate (TPE) process is a separate program run by Medicare Administrative Contractors. Under the CMS description of TPE, a MAC reviews 20 to 40 claims per round. Providers with errors get one-on-one education and at least 45 days to improve, with up to three rounds in total. If problems continue after the third round, CMS may move to 100 percent prepayment review, extrapolation or a referral to a Recovery Auditor.

Why it matters: TPE findings and RAC findings can point to the same weak spots. An internal billing audit that targets those areas early helps you pass a probe on the first round.

Choosing What to Audit: OIG Work Plan Compliance Alignment

OIG Work Plan compliance alignment means checking your services against the audits the HHS Office of Inspector General has announced. OIG updates the Work Plan on a rolling basis, and it lists the topics OIG is reviewing. If your practice bills services on that list, include them in your next internal billing audit.

  • Services on the current OIG Work Plan that your practice bills.
  • Codes where your use differs sharply from peers in your specialty.
  • Topics from recent TPE or RAC letters your practice received.
  • High-dollar services and services billed with modifiers such as 25 or 59.
  • New services, new providers and services added to your practice in the last year.

Certifying Medical Necessity in EHR Notes Before an Internal Billing Audit

Documentation decides audit outcomes. Certifying medical necessity in EHR notes means each record shows why the patient needed the service, who ordered it and who performed it. Auditors look for the same elements every time:

  • A clear reason for the visit or service, linked to the diagnosis on the claim.
  • A signed order or plan of care when the service requires one.
  • A legible, authenticated signature from the rendering provider.
  • Notes written for that visit, not copied forward without changes.
  • Time, units or other details that the billed code requires.

Auditors look closely at cloned or copy-forward notes. When every note reads the same, auditors may question whether the service on each date was medically necessary.

How to Run an Internal Billing Audit, Step by Step

An internal billing audit works best when it follows the same steps each time, so results compare from one cycle to the next.

  1. Define the scope. Pick the service, provider or time period, and write down why you chose it.
  2. Pull a random sample. Select claims at random from the period so the results reflect your real error rate.
  3. Review independently. Use a reviewer who did not code or bill the claims, such as a certified auditor.
  4. Record each finding. Note the error type, the correct code or outcome, and the dollar effect.
  5. Calculate error rates. Measure both the claim error rate and the dollar error rate.
  6. Correct and educate. Fix the root cause, train the providers involved and refund confirmed overpayments.

Our medical billing audit checklist gives a broader list of items to review in each cycle.

Error Rate Benchmark Calculation for an Internal Billing Audit

An error rate benchmark calculation gives you a number to track over time. Use two measures:

MeasureFormulaWhat it shows
Claim error rateClaims with an error ÷ claims reviewedHow often errors happen
Dollar error rateNet dollars paid in error ÷ total dollars reviewedHow much money the errors affect

Set your own threshold for action, and compare each audit with your previous results. Then, if a rate rises, widen the sample or review that area more often. For extra context, compare your error types with the topics in recent TPE letters from your MAC.

Extrapolation Risk in Medicare Audits

Extrapolation risk in Medicare audits is the main reason a small error rate can turn into a large demand. With extrapolation, a contractor reviews a statistical sample of claims and applies the error rate to the whole group of claims in the review period. Federal law allows Medicare contractors to use extrapolation when there is a sustained or high level of payment error, or when documented education has not fixed the problem.

Because the sample result scales up, accuracy in the sample matters. Keep complete records ready for every claim in a request, respond by the deadline, and review each finding before you accept it. If you disagree, the Medicare appeal process lets you challenge both the individual claim decisions and the statistical method. Our guide to reopenings, reconsiderations and appeals explains those steps.

Returning Overpayments Your Internal Billing Audit Finds

An internal billing audit that finds overpayments creates a duty to return them. Under federal law, providers must report and return Medicare overpayments within 60 days after identifying them. Starting in 2025, Medicare allows that deadline to pause for up to 180 days while a provider completes a timely, good-faith investigation. Document when you found each issue, what you reviewed and when you refunded it.

Example: A Hypothetical Internal Billing Audit

Consider a hypothetical multispecialty group that bills many high-level office visits. Its compliance officer pulls a random sample of 30 visits from the last six months. The review finds that several notes do not support the level billed, mostly because templates copy the same exam and plan forward. The group refunds the confirmed overpayments, removes copy-forward defaults from its templates and trains providers on the current E/M rules. Three months later, a follow-up audit of the same providers shows fewer errors.

Responding When an ADR Arrives

Even with a strong program, records requests will come. A calm, repeatable response protects you:

  1. Log the request. Record the date received, the due date, the claims listed and the contractor.
  2. Pull complete records. Include orders, notes, signatures, test results and any attestation needed for each claim.
  3. Review before sending. Check each record against the billed code, as you would in an internal billing audit.
  4. Send on time. Use the contractor's preferred method and keep proof of delivery.
  5. Track the outcome. Calendar the findings, discussion and appeal deadlines as soon as results arrive.

Building an Ongoing Audit Program

A single internal billing audit helps, but a schedule protects you. A practical schedule is to audit the highest-risk areas every quarter and all providers at least once a year. They also add focused audits after new services, new providers, payer policy changes or any TPE or RAC letter. Over time, the audit history itself becomes evidence of an effective compliance program.

If you want help building that program, our team works as proactive RCM compliance and denial prevention specialists for practices and facilities preparing for Medicare reviews.

Be ready before the RAC letter arrives

Dr Biller RCM runs internal billing audits, documentation reviews and appeal support for Medicare providers.

Contact Dr Biller RCM

Frequently Asked Questions

How far back can a RAC review claims?

Recovery Auditors can generally review claims up to three years after the date of payment. Patient status reviews have shorter limits when hospitals submit claims promptly.

What is the difference between a RAC audit and a TPE review?

A RAC is a Recovery Audit Contractor that reviews paid claims to find improper payments. TPE is a MAC program that reviews small samples of claims and adds education between rounds.

Should an internal audit use a random sample?

Yes, for measuring error rates. A random sample gives results that reflect your real billing. You can also run focused reviews of specific risks.

Who should perform an internal billing audit?

Someone independent of the coding and billing under review, such as a certified internal auditor or an outside audit team.

What happens if my audit finds an overpayment?

Report and return it within 60 days after you identify it. Medicare allows extra time for a timely, good-faith investigation before that clock runs.

Share:

More Posts

Book An Appointment